Classroom Without Walls Analysis Essay

Classrooms without walls

50 years ago, Marshall McLuhan the renound philosopher of communication theory wrote about the role of mass media (the press, radio and TV) in education. He argued that it should be treated as an educational equal to the book and not dismissed, as teachers defending their role in the educational process would have it, as mere “entertainment”. People would be exposed to far more information through TV and radio than they would ever be in books read at school and so threatened to crack “the very walls of the classroom”.

McLuhan viewed the introduction of the printing press and the books that they produced as a form of mass media that enabled education on a mass scale even though reading is regarded as being exactly the opposite of this as an individual pursuit.

50 years on, and TV, radio and the press are an accepted source of content in the classroom. McLuhan’s writing pre-dates but also pre-empts the Internet as the newest form of mass media which itself went through a period of being dismissed as entertainment before being accepted by teachers and academics as an educational equivalent to the book. These days, one rarely hears criticism of Wikipedia being a reliable primary source of information anymore.Over time, it has withstood tests of its credibility, its strengths and limitations are understood and generally its authority has become accepted.

The walls of the classroom have so-far withstood the assaults brought on by classroom-liberating technologies like the Internet. In higher education, there is simply too much invested in heavily walled institutions that equate buildings on campus with the gravitas of learning. At the same time, there is an acceptance however that this is unsustainable model.

More to the point, it misses out on the opportunities offered by the “mass” and collective experience offered by an approach that emphasises not only classrooms without walls, but one without borders. These are characteristics supported by, but not usually emphasised in, Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs). In part this is because the model of teaching implemented in the majority of MOOCs has mostly been about replicating the general model of teacher giving lectures and supplementing this with quizzes and tutorials. The forum does offer an opportunity for students to collaborate but this is more about problem solving and general discussion rather than necessarily promoting collaborative learning.

Taking a more active view of a classroom without borders means opening up the class to social, cultural and linguistic input from students and teachers at other institutions in other countries than your own. The immediate impact of doing this is to realise how narrow the focus is in classes that are only taught to a particular institution’s students. This ranges from a Princeton Introduction to Sociology class that after being run by as a MOOC caused the lecturer Mitch Duneir to realise how US focused the perspective of the course was. The eye-opening moment being when talking about the atrocities at Abu Ghraib he realised that this was focused solely on the experience of the US soldiers involved and their perspective as Americans. This was brought home to him when he realised that there were significant numbers of students from countries in that region and that their take on the incident was very different. Of the experience he said “I ended by thinking about how to bring the world back to the classroom in Princeton.”

Breaking the classroom walls also allows for collaboration. With research, collaboration between universities is taken as an essential element of producing high quality work. Some research is simply not possible without this level of collaboration because of the scale of the project, access to facilities and possibly most importantly, access to minds. In teaching, we have been slower to collaborate and is simply not facilitated by most institutions. There are obvious benefits to collaboration in teaching however and again technology is making this easier to do.

Guest lectures and even tutorials or discussions can be recorded using Skype or Google Hangout for example and watched live by students or at a later stage when viewing the recording. The collaboration could extend to sharing the teaching of classes across universities and even one university teaching a course at a second. Of course, this collaboration becomes even more beneficial when it spans borders and students are exposed to the different cultural and social elements as outlined previously, but enhanced by having academics and universities from these cultures contributing from within these different perspectives.

The timing is right for these changes. We have students who are adapted to using a global Internet and whose milieu is collaborative, multi-national and multi-cultural. The only aspect of their lives that isn’t is their schooling that is only now opening up with regular use of computers and the Internet. The same is true of their university that actively takes pride in the walls constraining their outlook and learning. The good news is that universities are beginning to recognize that the buildings are a liability and that they all have the potential to go beyond them. Source .

Relevant McLuhan Quotes:-

“The world communications net, the all-involving linkage of electric circuitry, will grow and become more sensitive. It will also develop new modes of feedback so that communication can become dialogue instead of monologue. It will breach the wall between “in” and “out” of school. It will join all people everywhere. When this has happened, we may at last realize that our place of learning is the world itself, the entire planet we live on. The little red schoolhouse is already well on its way toward becoming the little round schoolhouse”. – McLuhan, M. & Leonard, G.B. (1967, Feb. 21). The Future of Education: The Class of 1989. LOOK  Magazine. pp. 23-25.

“The telephone: speech without walls.

The phonograph: music hall without walls.

The photograph: museum without walls.

The electric light: space without walls.

The movie, radio, and TV: classroom without walls”. – Understanding Media, 1964

Like this:



Filed under: Academic, Articles, Commentary, Education, Ideas, New Media, Technology   |  Leave a Comment
Tags: academic, articles, communication, education, global village, ideas, Internet

"Do you have the flashlight?" Martha Mendoza asked as she made her way through the forest, eucalyptus leaves crackling beneath her shoes. Her destination, a damp cave, was not far from the road.

Mendoza (Kresge '89, journalism/education), a Pulitzer Prize–winning reporter for the Associated Press, teaches an investigative reporting class at UC Santa Cruz for graduate students in the Science Communication Program.

Most lessons take place in a classroom.

"But there comes a day in our semester when I tell them, 'Tomorrow, wear sturdy boots and be prepared to get muddy.' Usually they are mystified and excited," Mendoza said.

For professors across the disciplines, the redwood-lined, rugged, and occasionally spooky campus is a vast resource.

Taking advantage of the university's extremely unusual location, teachers are not afraid to have students cross creeks, dig through sticky mud, and get their hands—not to mention their pant legs—dirty.

The setting and learning are inextricably linked. At the Center for Agroecology & Sustainable Food Systems, apprentices learn organic gardening and farming. At the UCSC Arboretum, which houses the largest collection of Australian and South African plants outside their native countries, students volunteer and pursue internships. Over the years, student interns have conducted archaeological excavations within the Cowell Limeworks Historic District.

The land also inspires reflection and creativity; when College Eight lecturer Candace Calsoyas teaches freshman seminars on "Environment and Society," she leads students across the wooded campus while they walk, talk, and learn—a model that dates back to Aristotle, who founded the peripatetic school.

"Though UCSC is exceptionally beautiful with its mountain perch, majestic redwoods, and textured seascape below, still every landscape and cityscape suits the 'walk and talk,'" Calsoyas said. "Unlike being in the classroom, students don't feel put on the spot and are more liberated by being outside."

Over the years, UCSC's unique location has informed, enriched, and expanded the curriculum while allowing students to test their hunches and perfect their skills outdoors.

Spelunking witha skilled reporter

"Oh, look," Martha Mendoza said as she paused in a clearing. "It's a deer. And oh, there's a fawn. And another! Last time we were out here, a lizard ran right over a student's foot. It scared her."

Mendoza's experiential slogs are meant to help students learn to capture telling details on paper, even when they find themselves in unnerving places.

"Part of the lesson is being in an uncomfortable situation and still being observant," she said.

Gingerly, Mendoza lowered herself into the throat of the limestone cave, using a sturdy ladder. There were no sounds but Mendoza's breathing, the "droop-droop-droop" of an unseen water source, and the "smack" of her sunglasses, which fell off her face and landed in some dark corner of the cave.

Several of the campus caves provide habitat for rare cave invertebrates, some of which are believed to occur only on campus. These species are likely sensitive to disturbance, and educational users are informed about ways to minimize impacts while taking advantage of the opportunity to teach amidst and about these unique and rare organisms.

"A reporter has to be out of the comfort zone," Mendoza said as she turned on her flashlight, which only poked a hole in the dark. "If I'm in Haiti, reporting on exploratory drilling at a gold mine, and there's all this noise and people walking by with weapons, I have to really settle myself and say, 'What are these people wearing, and is it hot or cold out? What's going on?' Even if I had beautiful photos and video, it's just not the same as getting it down on paper in the moment."

Insects, chaparral, and scientific processes

Erika Zavaleta, associate professor of environmental studies, uses outdoor opportunities in every course she teaches—even 350-person lecture classes.

"UCSC has a huge diversity of ecosystems right on campus: mixed conifer forest, chaparral, grassland, redwood forest, riparian forest, streams, and of course agricultural lands," she said. "Where I grew up in the Northeast you would need to drive for hours to cross through this many kinds of ecosystems."

Zavaleta takes an inquiry-based approach, giving students the chance to explore an area and wrestle with such questions as, "Are there more kinds of insects in the forest or the chaparral?"

Students haul field guides, compasses, transect tapes, and nets into the field. Soon they've made graphs and drawn up posters to present to the class.

"I hear them talk about what an exciting thing it is to think and problem-solve for themselves, and get out and actually do science rather than just hearing about it," Zavaleta said.

"Just the simple experience of looking in the right places for salamanders and finding them, or of trying to figure out why the forest ends and the grassland starts right at a particular place, lights up so many students," Zavaleta continued. "They connect places with intellectual ideas and practical skills."

Stalking the elusive microphage

The students of Grant Hartzog, professor of molecular, cell, and developmental (MCD) biology, take to the forest in search of bacteriophages, viruses that attack bacteria.

So many exist in nature that they are thought to kill off a large proportion of bacteria on planet Earth every day. Still, students must prowl around in search of them.

First they isolate the virus from the soil, photograph it with help from an electron microscope, and extract its DNA. Then a laboratory takes a close look at the DNA sequence.

When it comes to phage hunting and genetic documentation, "you don't need an abundance of technical skills to be successful right away," Hartzog said. "You need to be enthusiastic, curious, and willing to learn."

The result is original findings.

"Every student is doing the same kind of technical manipulations, but each is collecting a unique virus," Hartzog said. "This means that although these beginning students are working together on similar projects, they are doing authentic research and making a real contribution. They take a project and have total ownership of it."

They even get to name the newly discovered phages. So far, undergraduates have dubbed them Darth, FlowerChild, Haze, Jeffabunny, TreeBaby, Zigzag, Rage, Lugosi, DomoArigato, and Firecracker, among other names.

One of Hartzog's students, Daniel McKernan (Oakes '14, human biology), quickly learned that some areas on campus are better than others for finding phages.

"It is best to collect soil samples in damper shaded areas," he said. "I collected about 15 soil samples here on campus at UCSC in the dirtiest, muddiest, smelliest areas I could find.

"The search was fun," McKernan said. "It took hiking in creek beds and digging through mud. It was interesting to go out in search of stagnant, wet soil."

The next step was examining the phage using an electron microscope.

"If the phage that I have isolated is novel, meaning that it has never before been discovered, I think I will name it after my dog, Broseph," McKernan said.

Reading a forest, leaf by leaf

In late summer, five student interns ventured out into the UCSC Campus Natural Reserve, 400 acres of protected natural lands on the 2,000-acre campus.

They were heading out toward the 15-acre Forest Ecology Reseach Plot (FERP), a research and teaching site established by environmental studies professor Greg Gilbert five years ago. There, students and scientists have catalogued and tagged more than 10,000 individual plants, including Douglas-fir, coast live oak, Shreve oak, and tanoak.

These students—mostly undergrads, but also a couple of newly minted UCSC graduates—are all paid interns, advancing science by helping with the FERP research project, spending eight hours a day, five days a week, in the forest.

Cave care

UCSC's caves are sensitive habitats that require careful stewardship by all.

Appropriate use of the campus caves is limited to research and occasional guided visits for university classes, during which students are informed about ways to minimize impacts while taking advantage of the opportunity to learn about the area's unique geology and its rare subterranean organisms, according to Alex Jones, Campus Natural Reserve steward.

Jones urges visitors to be sensitive to flora and fauna throughout the campus's natural areas, including its caves.

"Caves on and around the UCSC campus provide habitat for rare cave invertebrates, including the Dollof cave spider and the Empire Cave pseudoscorpion, which are believed to occur only within these caves," Jones said. "These species and the caves' geologic features are vulnerable to disturbances caused by recreational use. Substantial degradation of cave features has been documented within the past few decades since their discovery."

"There's nothing else like this in the UC system," said Gage Dayton, director of UCSC Natural Reserves. "You can learn a lot in the lecture hall or lab. But if you want to get a feel for what poison oak looks like, bang a hammer on a rock, dig a pitfall to trap and catch an animal, measure light penetration in a real forest, and capture and analyze water from a creek, you just can't get that in the classroom or a laboratory. And this is right outside our door."

Getting students out to natural areas would have been logistically difficult and expensive "if you had to find buses for all of them," Dayton said. "But this is five minutes from the door of traditional classrooms. All students should be getting out here and using it."

Along the way, the students get an intimate knowledge of how science works and best practices in research. They also have fun, making deliberately geeky jokes about "liking lichens" and sampling huckleberries straight off the vine.

The huckleberries are of the same genus as blueberries, explained Alex Chacon, 19 (College Nine '15, plant science). "They're the worst plants to measure because of how bushy they are and how many stems they have."

They insist that a visitor sniff a sprig of spicy wild mint and feel the contours of asmooth hazelnut leaf. They express sympathy for a western fence lizard that someone, perhaps a speeding bicyclist, has squished on the trail, and marvel at a strewn-about deer carcass.

In the process, they grow their scientific skills hour by hour, day by day.

"When you work on someone else's project you start seeing how scientists think," said Kathlyn Franco, 22 (Cowell '12, environmental studies), who wants to be a mammalogist.

"You start seeing how they find and fix mistakes and how to find a better way," Franco continued. "You start building all these ways of seeing and doing. Gage [Dayton] will often answer my questions with questions: 'What are the drawbacks and benefits of doing this?'"

To trek with these bright students through the reserves, past thick stands of chaparral, Douglas-fir, and madrones with peeling bark, is to see the campus landscape in a completely different light. At last they arrived at the FERP, where every single shrub and tree of a certain height and diameter is being studied.

Considering this whole place is a living laboratory, it makes sense that the students suddenly stopped and put on what appeared to be lab coats. Actually, they were lightweight all-white Tyvek suits, designed to protect them from one of the plants they're studying— native poison oak.

"Poison oak is very interesting," observed Catherine Scheid, 20 (Cowell '14, environmental studies), who has no fear of the nasty stuff. She may be immune. "It takes different forms. It can grow like a shrub. Sometimes it looks like a little tree."

The students were accompanied by Alex Jones, UCSC Campus Natural Reserve steward. Student interns spend so much time out here with him that they've started to know the forest intimately.

"A Cooper's Hawk nested here in the spring," Jones observed. "The female used to dive-bomb the interns. Now they're at the stage when we can hear three chicks begging for food."

Share this story:TwitterFacebookGoogle+LinkedInReddit

Categories: 1

0 Replies to “Classroom Without Walls Analysis Essay”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *